We Buy Gold and Silver, Coins, Stamps, Jewelry, and More!

Welcome to Shorewood Coin Shop, Located Shorewood, WI

Shorewood Coin Shop buys and sells rare coins with exceptional expertise. We are a full-service coin shop dealing in all areas of numismatics dealing currency, ancient coins, and so much more.

You've come to the right place if you're looking to buy or sell coins, paper currency, or gold and silver jewelry. We offer some of the best prices in the area. Our inventory is continually changing, so please check back often. We add new items frequently.

Coin collecting supplies and numismatic literature are also available.

Gold and Silver Coins | Shorewood, WI | Shorewood Coin Shop

What We Offer

Coins
Rare Coins and Currency
Paying Top Dollar for Coins
Vintage Pocket and Wrist Watches
Flatware
Gold, Silver, Platinum
Some Collectibles
Antique and Estate Jewelry
Stamps

Professional Appraisals

Have you found something in your attic or at an estate sale that seems valuable? Schedule a consultation with Shorewood Coin Shop. We evaluate more than just coins. We buy gold and silver jewelry in any condition, diamond rings, pocket watches, sterling silver flatware, and even bullion.

Let our professionals take a look at what you have and let us give you a fair and knowledgeable price.

Do you need to know the value of an item for an estate? We are here to help. Visit us, or we'll come to your location in the Milwaukee, WI area. We provide accurate and knowledgeable evaluations and upfront values based on the current market value for gold, silver, and other minerals.

We’re excited to meet you and discover how we can work together to give you the best price on your item.

Slide title

★★★★★

Came in with a sorted 10,000 coin family collection and Nick, Jeff & Alex stayed late and had it completely appraised in 90 minutes. They know their stuff! I agree with the reviews about fair pricing and very friendly service. I left very satisfied, and with their trusted contact information for a dealer interested in another collection I am selling. Don’t understand the reviews bashing the shop appearance … it isn’t a beauty parlor, but it’s exactly what I would expect for a family run small coins and collectibles shop.

- Jim B.

Button
Slide title

★★★★★

After my father in law passed away I stopped into the shop to sell his coin collection, which was three boxes of mostly lower value collector books and binders full of coins. There was nothing really special in the collection, but everyone in this shop was very friendly and knowledgeable, and they gave me a very fair price. I really appreciated their patience and expertise, and I would definitely recommend them!

- ehall720

Button
Slide title

★★★★★

This place employs an honest people who are always friendly and informative with all your coins/gold/silver/interesting items. Highly recommended.

- Awoken33

Button
Slide title

★★★★★

Quaint little shop, cluttered and a bit grungy, but in weirdly inviting way. All the staff were very friendly and made me feel welcome. Good prices on all items. Will be back.

- Jerry W.

Button
Slide title

★★★★★

First impression was a tad iffy but they won me over. Friendly staff and very fair value and assessment. They are open about prices and what I had. I sound highly recommend coming to them for coins and other vintage items.

- Brandon B.

Button